Old ice maker: one ejector blade out of line (circled)
Last updated:
Case Study · Sub-Zero BI-48SID · Woodinville, WA
The call was about a knocking noise from the freezer of a 48-inch Sub-Zero side-by-side in Woodinville. On site, Max found three things wrong, and none of them were the same problem: the ice maker had failed, the refrigerator door gasket was no longer sealing, and the refrigerator drain was clogged. All three were fixed on the same visit, November 17, 2026.
Before touching anything
Every Sub-Zero has a rating plate inside the cabinet. It is the first thing worth photographing when you call for service, because it answers most of the questions a technician would otherwise ask over the phone. Here is what this one shows.
Model BI-48SID/S/PH. A 48-inch built-in side-by-side with an ice maker in the freezer. The model number is what parts are ordered against, so the ice maker and gasket on this job were matched to it.
Built April 2017. Sub-Zero built-in refrigeration can last 20–35+ years, so at this age the cabinet, compressors, and sealed systems are far from the end of their life. Wear parts like an ice maker and a door gasket are a different story, and that is what failed here.
Two refrigerant charges: 4.00 oz refrigerator, 5.50 oz freezer. The plate lists a separate charge for each side because each side has its own sealed system. That matters for diagnosis: a problem in the freezer and a problem in the refrigerator can have nothing to do with each other, which turned out to be the case on this visit.
The visit, in order
The homeowner’s description was a knocking from the freezer that stopped whenever the freezer door was opened, with no visible ice buildup. The ice maker was not working. With the ice bin out, the old assembly came out of the freezer. On the bench, one of its ejector blades sits out of line with the rest (circled in the photo below). The whole ice maker assembly was replaced with a new one. More on this part on our Sub-Zero ice maker repair page.
A Sub-Zero gasket is a magnetic seal that has to close tight along the full length of the door. This one was no longer sealing. A gasket that doesn’t seal lets warm, humid kitchen air into the cabinet every hour the door is closed. The refrigerator door got a new gasket.
During defrost, water runs off the evaporator into a drain and down to a pan under the unit, where it evaporates. When that drain clogs, the water has nowhere to go; the usual result is water on the floor or ice building up inside the refrigerator. The drain system was cleaned out. No part was needed for this one, only labor. Our Sub-Zero maintenance guide covers what you can check yourself between visits.
Real photos
Old ice maker: one ejector blade out of line (circled)
Old and new ice maker assemblies, side by side
New ice maker in, freezer put back together
Refrigerator door with the new gasket installed
Questions
Because the refrigerator and freezer each have their own sealed system. This BI-48SID’s plate lists 4.00 oz for the refrigerator and 5.50 oz for the freezer. It also means a problem on one side often has nothing to do with the other.
In most cases, yes. Sub-Zero built-in refrigeration can last 20–35+ years. This 2017 unit needed wear parts (an ice maker and a gasket) plus a drain cleaning, not a sealed system repair. See our repair-or-replace guide for how to weigh it on your own unit.
Yes, when the parts are available. This job covered an ice maker, a door gasket, and a drain cleaning in one visit. You get one price for everything before work begins; see the Sub-Zero repair cost guide for typical ranges.
Yes. This job was in Woodinville, and so was this Sub-Zero 700BFI freezer rebuild. We serve King and Snohomish County, including Woodinville, Bothell, Kirkland, and Redmond.
Sub-Zero repairs come with a 1-year warranty, and we use genuine Sub-Zero parts. Ace Appliance Service LLC is licensed and insured in Washington State, WA contractor #ACEAPAS774K6.
The ice maker itself can fail, as it did here, but so can the water supply to it, like the water fill valve or a frozen line. We check the supply before replacing the ice maker. More on our Sub-Zero ice maker repair page.
Close the door on a sheet of paper at a few spots around the door and pull it out. If it slides out with almost no resistance anywhere, the gasket isn’t sealing there. Look for torn, flattened, or stiff sections too.
A clogged defrost drain is a common cause. Defrost water can’t reach the pan under the unit, so it ends up on the floor or freezes inside. Cleaning the drain system, as on this job, is labor only, with no part needed.
Ready when you are
Call now for the fastest response, or send us a few details and we'll call you back within one business hour.
(425) 533-0823 Call Now · Same-Day ServiceMon–Fri, 8am–6pm